The Long Island Bar Menu (Update 2025)
The Long Island Bar in Brooklyn Heights offers a cozy and festive atmosphere with creative cocktails and delicious food. The menu features appetizers like Fried Cheese Curds and Buffalo Fried Cauliflower, mains including Pasta Primavera and The L.I. Burger, and desserts like Fried Apple Pies and Butterscotch Pudding. Customers rave about the cheese curds, burgers, and strong martinis. The classic retro vibe, attentive service, and well-crafted cocktails make it a must-visit spot in the neighborhood. While the menu may be limited, the quality of the dishes and drinks is top-notch. The Long Island Bar is perfect for grabbing drinks with friends, enjoying a lively ambiance, and indulging in flavorful bites. Whether you're looking for a place to unwind after work or gather with loved ones, this establishment has something for everyone.
Appetizers
Nuts
Olives
Pretzels
Fried Cheese Curds
with buttermilk-onion dip
Surryano Virginia Ham
with romesco sauce and olive oil torta
Trout Roe & Rye Crackers
with smoked fish spread & dill
Buffalo Fried Cauliflower
house buffalo sauce, blue cheese dip & crudites
Carrot Salad
with sunflower, orange, chili, golden raisins, & feta
Brussels Sprouts
shaved thin with radicchio, pomegranate, bacon, and maple
Pasta "Primavera"
with ramps, morels, asparagus, chicken thigh & egg yolk
Pennsylvania Brook Trout
with farro, broccoli, carrot sauce, sunchoke & nasturtium
E. L. T. Sandwich
eggplant, grilled lettuce, tomato & mayo on sourdough
Merguez Frites
fleisher's spicy lamb sausage on baguette with harissa & fries
The L. I. Burger
two fleisher's beef patties, pickles, cheese, fancy sauce, & fries
Side of Fries
Mains
Dessert
Fried Apple Pies
with whipped vanilla sauce
Butterscotch Pudding
with brown butter cookies & a cherry on top